Tuesday, October 24, 2017
Importance of Jury Selection
As we travel further and deeper into this OJ Simpson case, I realize the importance of the jury and how they can truly make or break the case before they even hit the courthouse. I have also realized that it is a lot more difficult to pick a good jury for your side than most think. In the case of the Dan White, the former San Francisco City Hall Supervisor, he got off a lot easier than most when they commit a double murder. This case wasn't obviously all decided by jury selection but this shows the difficulty of jury selection. The defendants wanted to choose the conservative jury because they may have a bias towards White because he was also a conservative. On the other hand, the prosecution felt that a conservative jury would help their case because conservatives are for the death penalty that comes with a double murder. In the end, he got voluntary manslaughter which resulted in an immensely softer penalty of 7 years. There were a couple jurors in the OJ case that were in the film that we watched that completely stunned me on how much they were missing from the evidence and how little they knew about the evidence. Especially the DNA because that was a key piece of evidence against OJ that was nearly impossible to debunk or defend against. Bottom line is, there is certainly an advantage gained for one side or the other in the jury selection so choose wisely.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I believe that Jurys should just be a random sample of the population. Other wise no matter what I feel like there would be bias because both sides are trying to pick Jurys that suit themselves.
ReplyDeleteI think that comment in the film where other people who study the justice system said that if there was a white jury, OJ would've been guilty of his crimes. I think that's somewhat believable because of the reaction of the white community after OJ was acquitted was full of anger. But, some of the jury members that were interviewed that were African american said their decision was based on the evidence presented. So I guess the jury selection is important.
ReplyDeletenot the OJ Made in America film, the film we're watching in large group.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWhen choosing a jury it is almost impossible to make sure that their is no bias. Whether or not people want to admit it, prejudice and stereotypes always come into play and it would not be easy to find a truthfully fair and honest jury.
ReplyDelete