Since OJ was such a prominent athlete, I think we can use a sports metaphor to relate to his trial. Sometimes in a game, a referee will make a bad call. For example, they call a ball that clearly landed out as in. The team that lost the point from this will be extremely upset, but the team that benefitted from it will kind of look the other way and shrug. They know that they didn't really earn that point but they're willing to take it anyway. Perhaps the referee realizes their mistake but instead of overturning their call or calling a replay they will let the game go on. Replaying or overturning would undermine their authority. Instead, on the next play, they might do a "make-up call" like calling a double on the setter whose team had just benefitted from the last point.
I think if you view OJ as a make-up call it makes a lot more sense. Obviously, the black community had had their fair share of bad calls, with Rodney King being the latest and most publicized. The white community had turned their cheek and ignored the injustice in the system. Even if OJ was guilty (which I believe he was), having something finally land their way, even if it was wrong felt like a victory to the black community. When they were cheering, they weren't cheering for him, they were cheering that finally, something had gone in their favor when everything up until that point had not. Do you think this metaphor is accurate? Has it oversimplified the feelings around the case?
That's a very interesting way to view the case! But who would represent "the referee" in this case? That's the only oversimplification I see, because there was not one entity that really swayed the case.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis metaphor fits this case really well, but would the "referee" be the jury?
ReplyDeleteI can easily relate to the whole sports metaphor of make-up calling as I have experienced it multiple times. I agree with your take on the case and how the authorities wouldn't take back a call because it would make them look bad. I do think however that the black community was also cheering for him, not just that something had gone in their favor, because he had made such an impact on the black peoples' lives as he succeeded in school and sports early on in life and made his name big.
ReplyDelete